Compare ShipHero, Extensiv 3PL Warehouse Manager, Logiwa and Deposco on one client through one complete fulfillment cycle. ShipBob WMS is an option if you run a brand's own warehouse. If your WMS works but one portal, report or integration doesn't, check whether that gap can be fixed without replacing it.
Vendor information below was read from official product and pricing pages on October 11, 2026. It shows documented capabilities, not a hands-on ranking.
Shortlist the software for the warehouse you actually run
A 3PL needs client-specific stock access, rate cards and invoices to work together. An order-management product or an outsourced fulfillment service is not automatically a replacement for your warehouse system.
| Candidate | A reason to evaluate it | The deciding demonstration |
|---|---|---|
| ShipHero | Ecommerce fulfillment with multi-client billing, a customer portal and warehouse execution. | Take one client's order through picking, shipping, portal updates and the charges your team must bill. |
| Extensiv 3PL Warehouse Manager | A 3PL needs warehouse workflows alongside Extensiv's billing, scanning and integration products. | Show which products handle each step and what the written quote includes. |
| Logiwa | A fulfillment operation wants to test warehouse automation and client-specific billing together. | Apply a real client's rates to receipts, storage, handling and returns, then check the accounting handoff. |
| Deposco | A 3PL needs to evaluate warehouse execution, order routing, billing and client visibility across its operation. | Run a representative order and client bill, including routing across facilities if that matters to you. |
| ShipBob WMS | A brand wants software for its own warehouse, with a possible connection to outsourced fulfillment. | Confirm eligibility, shipping arrangements and the work your own warehouse retains. For multi-client 3PL use, ask explicitly about suitability. |
Keep your current provider in the evaluation: a configuration change, a different package or an existing connector may fix the problem with less disruption.
Searching for 3PL Central alternatives? The current product is Extensiv 3PL Warehouse Manager, per Extensiv's rebrand announcement. Name the product in your demo and quote; "Extensiv" covers more than one application.
ShipHero versus Extensiv: follow one client from receipt to invoice
ShipHero's current 3PL overview describes billing, self-service client visibility, mobile picking and an API. Extensiv's product overview describes warehouse execution and points to related products such as Billing Manager and SmartScan. Ask which components you would actually buy.
Give both the same scenario: one client, a receipt, an order with a change, a shipment, a return, plus any value-added work that affects the invoice. Have a warehouse lead, account manager and finance user each complete their part.
Decide on four questions:
- Can the operator finish the task on the scanner they use?
- Can the client see the right status without calling?
- Can finance explain the bill from recorded activity?
- Who can correct a mistake, and who sees the correction?
Price the setup that covers the work your team currently does outside the system, not a smaller scope.
What do ShipHero and Extensiv alternatives cost?
Get written quotes for the same operating scenario. The sources below do not give one comparable monthly price across all five products. Confirm currency, taxes, term, implementation and optional charges with each vendor.
| Product | Current public pricing reference | What to confirm in your proposal |
|---|---|---|
| ShipHero | Its current landing page requests a custom quote based on order volume. | Included users, seasonal seats, client access, facilities, integrations, hardware and onboarding. |
| Extensiv 3PL Warehouse Manager | The reviewed product page directs buyers to a tailored walkthrough rather than an itemised subscription price. | The actual WMS, billing, scanning and integration products required, their charges and implementation scope. |
| Logiwa | Its pricing page describes a custom plan based on fulfillment volume and complexity, with unlimited users. | Peak-volume assumptions, included core functions and integrations, and any work outside the agreed plan. |
| Deposco | The reviewed 3PL page directs buyers to a demo rather than a standard subscription amount. | The required warehouse, order-routing, billing and portal scope, plus rollout and ongoing costs. |
| ShipBob WMS | Its page lists implementation, a monthly software fee and shipping costs, with unlimited users and warehouses. | Eligibility, carrier arrangements, wholesale/EDI costs and any outsourced fulfillment scope. |
ShipBob's WMS pricing page describes US warehouses shipping 3,500 to 120,000 orders per month; confirm eligibility with the provider. Don't compare a fulfillment-service bill with a software subscription.
On ShipHero seats, current user documentation discusses seat limits and says deactivating a user does not automatically reduce billing. Get the seasonal staffing arrangement in writing.
Compare the first year and the following year
Use the same normal-month and peak-month assumptions for every quote: orders, clients, facilities, staff roles, integrations. Include software, setup, migration, devices, training, support and the systems that remain.
- Keep carrier postage and outsourced warehouse services as separate lines. One vendor may bundle them and another not.
- Ask what changes the price at renewal, and what happens when you add volume, clients or a facility. "Unlimited users" describes access, not a fixed total cost.
- Put a custom build in the same sheet, with its running, maintenance and change costs. A lower subscription alone doesn't prove a replacement pays back.
Check the client portal and billing before you switch
A portal should cut the conversations your account team repeats. List what clients need to do (see stock, check a shipment, request a change, download a report, understand an invoice) and test each with a client-level login.
- Use two test clients with similar SKUs and different access. Each must see only its own records.
- Permissions must match the contract, and a stale status must be recognisable.
- For any action that changes an order, agree who approves it and how the warehouse receives it.
Test billing separately. Use a real rate card and representative activity with confidential details removed: receiving, storage, picking, packing, returns and extra services. Have finance reconcile charges, minimums, adjustments and credits.
Do not assume Logiwa needs a separate tool for all 3PL billing. Its billing documentation describes client-specific contract rates and billing reports. Extensiv Billing Manager is also a documented product. Check native configuration and supported accounting handoffs before proposing a new billing application.
If the WMS already records the work and applies the rates, the missing piece may be configuration or a usable report. If it can't capture the activity, a portal won't make invoices accurate.
Integrations: separate access limits from charges
A connector logo is a starting point. Ask what moves between the WMS, store, carrier and accounting system, in which direction and how fast. Have the demo include an order amendment, cancellation, return, failed update and duplicate message.
ShipHero's API documentation describes replenishing complexity credits and request-rate limits. Those limits are not evidence of a dollar charge for every exchange. Extensiv documents an open REST API. API access doesn't mean every record or action you need is supported.
Confirm limits, any charges and peak-traffic delay, and name who monitors and resolves failed updates. If your platform handles stock and shipping reliably, an integration that removes one retyping step may beat replacing warehouse execution.
Plan migration around stock, orders and client records
Before switching, test what you can export and what the new system can import: client ownership, SKU identifiers, locations, stock, lots or serials, open orders, returns, billing records, attachments and history.
ShipHero's Data Exports documentation describes full and delta exports through its API. An export doesn't prove another WMS can recreate every record, permission or relationship. Ask both providers for the supported transfer process and your account's export terms.
Pilot with one client or facility. Reconcile physical and system stock, check open orders, inspect invoices and carrier records, and have the team practise corrections.
Give one system responsibility for live stock updates, order processing and shipping labels at each stage. Parallel runs should use copied records or a separate pilot scope, never two systems allocating the same stock. Write down the cutover owner, data freeze, stock check and rollback conditions first.
Confirm renewal, cancellation notice and continuing access in writing, and archive records that can't move. For a fuller playbook, see the migration plan.
If one gap remains
If a vendor can demonstrate the full job at a quote that fits, choose or configure that product.
If one gap remains, such as a client dashboard with the right permissions, a failed-update review queue, a billing reconciliation report or a handoff between your WMS and another system, check native configuration and integrations first. If they don't cover it, a focused 3PL build around your current WMS may.
Focused custom projects start at US$5,000. The planning reference is six to ten months of subscription spend the finished project could actually replace, and the minimum still applies. For example, US$1,000 a month of replaceable spend gives a US$6,000 to US$10,000 reference, subject to scope. It is not a payback promise: a portal added to an existing WMS doesn't remove the WMS subscription, and hosting, external tools, support and future changes are separate. Full WMS replacement is quoted separately after discovery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Compare ShipHero, Extensiv 3PL Warehouse Manager, Logiwa and Deposco using the same client, fulfillment cycle and billing rules. Test the required package and written quote rather than choosing a universal winner. ShipBob WMS is another option for eligible businesses operating their own warehouse; confirm suitability for your operating model.
The reviewed vendor pages do not establish one comparable monthly price. ShipHero requests an order-volume-based quote; Logiwa describes volume-and-complexity pricing with unlimited users. Obtain written proposals for the actual Extensiv and Deposco scope. ShipBob WMS lists implementation, monthly software and shipping charges. Compare setup, migration, retained systems and support as well as the subscription.
First test native configuration and supported portal options. If the WMS still handles inventory and shipping well, a focused dashboard or integration may solve the gap with less operational change. Check client isolation, permissions, record freshness and any approved write-back actions. Adding a portal does not automatically remove the WMS subscription.
Often, for a defined workflow, portal or integration. Focused projects start at US$5,000, with a planning reference of six to ten months of subscription spend the project could actually replace. Full WMS replacement is quoted separately, and running costs, external services and support are extra.
Want to improve one handoff before replacing the WMS?
Explore focused client portal, billing and integration scopes, with project evidence, budget guidance and delivery responsibilities.
